Day 28–The best he could

I’m very thankful to the guest writers who participated in the “28 days of love” project this month. It’s been inspiring to read about the various ways love and gratitude coincide in so many very different people’s lives. I had guest writers lined up every day, but a few people weren’t able to write their posts, and it left me wondering what to do about today’s post, the last of the series.

I have a nice generic piece about gratitude sitting in front of me on my desk that I thought about posting. It’s very well-written , but when I sat down to post it, something gave me pause. It was that same nagging feeling I get when I know something isn’t right or when God is trying to get my attention in that mysterious, silent way of His. So I took my hands off the keyboard, folded them in my lap for a moment, and said a very short prayer.

“God, if there’s something else you want me to write about, let me know right now.”

He answered.

With my dad, probably taken the year my parents got divorced
With my dad, probably taken the year my parents got divorced

“Your dad.”

Then I wished I hadn’t asked.

It’s not easy to write about. It never has been.

Once I attended a poetry workshop at Lyon College by my former professor, Andrea Hollander Budy, and a visiting writer, Peter Abbs, whose beautiful, smooth recitations still echo in my ears when I read his poetry seven years later.

One of our assignments was to write a poem, in similar fashion to one of his, about gifts we’d received from someone significant in our lives. I wrote about my mom and all the ways she’d impacted me. I know the poem hides in the recesses of a maroon binder in the bottom of a storage box in our quilting house next door, but I don’t have the time to find it today. Each stanza begins, “From my mother” and then lists a gift I’ve received from her, namely lessons and principles she has passed on to me.

The last stanza, which has haunted me since writing it, is about my father.

“From my father,


worth having

or wanting.”

When I read the poem aloud after listening to beautiful odes to wonderful people by the other aspiring poets at the workshop, Peter Abbs had the reaction I always shoot for when writing last lines to poems.


What heavy words I’d written.

Sadly, they were true.

My father has nine biological children. He is currently raising one of them. The others were raised by their mothers or other generous people without financial support. He was consumed with other things. Drugs, namely.

Favorite softball season ever, with my dad as assistant coach
Favorite softball season ever, with my dad as assistant coach

My father is an addict. His addiction has led him to make countless poor decisions, hurtful decisions, which have cost him his relationships with almost all of his children and most of his grandchildren, not to mention the mothers of his children, his friends, and his other family members. During his periods of sobriety, he is brilliant, hilarious, animated, inspiring, loving, and thoughtful. During the periods when he is ravaged by addiction, he is not.

About five years ago, my father faced legal consequences for his addiction-related actions. He began attending 12-step meetings, and it changed his life. At the same time, I was working the steps in my own 12-step program for family members and loved ones of alcoholics. I reached the point of making a list of people I needed to make amends to. My father fell into the category of “maybe never,” meaning I knew I owed him an amends, but I was not ready yet, and I might never be.

God decided to move my dad up on the list, though. I began to feel that nagging feeling about making amends to my father. I called him on my way home from a meeting one night and managed to choke out the words.

“Dad, I need to make an amends to you. I have hated you my whole life for what you have done and haven’t done for me and my sisters. I hated you for the way you treated my mom. I want you to know I forgive you, and I know you have an addiction, and please let me know if there’s something I can do to make it up to you.”


Then words wet with tears came through.

“You don’t need to do anything for me. I owe you an amends.”

So that day, in 2008, we made mutual amends to one another. For the first time in my life, I felt completely at peace with my father. Well into my late 20s, I had no desire to attempt to form some warm and fuzzy father-daughter bond with him. That seemed unrealistic. But I felt good knowing that we’d cleared the air between us, and we occasionally talked on the phone, and it wasn’t as awkward as it had been my whole life. When I said “I love you,” I meant it. I no longer felt forced to say “I love you” to someone who I felt had not demonstrated real love to me.

Things changed. My dad’s addiction got the best of him again. He served a prison sentence. He willingly placed his two youngest children in the care of other people. And the little girl in me felt her head drop in disappointment. It seemed the same old story just picked up where it had left off.

Today, I choose to refrain from contacting my father, and he knows why. But I see things a little differently today than I used to.

In my heart, thanks to my own spiritual growth and work in my recovery program, I’ve written a new closing stanza to that heavy poem.

“From my father,

four sisters and four brothers.

A shining memory of gifts

wrapped in aluminum foil

under a miniature Christmas tree.

A moment of complete

safety on the back of his Harley,

eyes closed, hugging him close

at five years old.

The most fun I’ve ever had

playing softball.

A dozen roses at 29,

the card reading, ‘Daddy loves you.’

From my father,

the best love

he could give

at the time

with what he had.”

The most meaningful bouquet I've ever received
The most meaningful bouquet I’ve ever received


23 thoughts on “Day 28–The best he could

Add yours

  1. I’ve been thinking a lot lately about forgiveness, and realizing that it is different from reconciliation. Thanks for listening to the Holy Spirit and sharing about your father…I’ve had my own share of family issues. This brought tears to my eyes.

    1. Thank you, Jenny, for letting me know that what I wrote struck a chord with you. That’s always confirmation to me that I did the right thing by writing when I would have rather not.

  2. I have always said the portion of John 8:32, “…the truth shall make you free” reaches much further than we can imagine. A story like this one is what makes me say so.

  3. Wow! I can relate as i have difficult issues with my Mother still and she has been gone for nine years. Thank you! Your writings have shown me how to look at the positive, instead of dwelling on the scars which i have been doing recently.

  4. Thanks Pastor Paul! I’m so glad to hear you say that many took ownership of it. That was my hope. I hope many of the great guest writers this month (including YOU) will consider sending me posts from time to time as the notion hits you.
    I’m also grateful that I’ve been able to find things to be grateful for. They’re always there. Sometimes just harder to see.

  5. Bethany, a very heavy ending to our “Month of Gratitude.” I say ‘our’ because I think many of us took ownership of it. What a blessing that you have progressed far enough in your walk that you can see some good things from your father. Love and blessings, girl…

  6. I’m sorry, Henry. I didn’t really know about your dad. My younger siblings have way fewer memories, if any, of my dad, so I feel a lot of grief for them and what they missed out on. At least I do have some good memories. And that is what I have become grateful for, thanks to recovery and the help of my sponsor. Realizing that I can focus on the negatives or positives. I just choose the positives more often now. Doesn’t erase the negatives, but it keeps my focus elsewhere, and that keeps me in a better place emotionally for sure. Thankfully Maggie is the luckiest baby ever and has a wonderful dad, and I am getting to watch them interact every single day. It’s strangely a way I think God is healing my hurts.

  7. Wow, Bethany, that’s some powerful stuff. I wish you weren’t so far away or i’d give ya a hug. I have dad issues too, mine left before I was born, ran away from me at age 5 when i tried to get a picture with him in a safeway parking lot, my Godfather handed him a written letter i sent and he put it in his pocket and told him,”I have enough troubles.” So I can somewhat empathize. But yeah, deep stuff. Takes a lot to put that out there

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: